NMDC Ltd. share price target

1QFY20 adj. EBITDA of INR19.3b (-4% QoQ) was in line with our estimate of INR18.9b. The sequential decline in EBITDA was due to lower volumes, partly offset by higher realizations. Adj. PAT was down 6% QoQ at INR12.8b (in-line). Production was down 20% QoQ (+21% YoY) to 8.4mt, while sales declined 15% QoQ (+28% YoY) to 8.7mt (in-line). Domestic reported realization was up INR89 QoQ to INR2,916/t on the back of price hikes (INR200-250/t in May). In case of the Donimalai mine, a new lease agreement has to be signed with...

Favourable high court ruling also augurs well Karnataka High Court has ruled in favour of NMDC with regard to royalty issue in case of Donimalai mine. Earlier, Karnataka had levied 80% royalty on the Donimalai mine during the time of lease renewal. In this regard, NMDC had filed a writ petition in the high court against the royalty of 80% levied by the Karnataka government on average sales value of iron ore from the Donimalai mine. The writ petition is allowed and the earlier condition to impose premium equivalent to 80% of average sale price of iron ore has...

Model sales volume of 31, 32 MT for FY20, 21, respectively For FY19, NMDC reported production volume of 32.36 MT, down 9.1% YoY, while it reported sales volume of 32.36 MT, down 10.8% YoY. The volume during FY19 was impacted on account of suspension of operations at NMDC's Donimalai iron ore mine. NMDC Donimalai mine has remained shut since November 2018, on account of royalty dispute with Karnataka government. The high court verdict is awaited for the same. The outcome of this verdict remain a key monitorable. Without Donimalai mine, NMDC...

Operational decline as expected on lower realizations Donimalai mine lease resolution to drive re-rating; Maintain Buy 4QFY19 adj. EBITDA of INR20b (-12% QoQ) came in line with our estimate of INR19.6b. EBITDA is adjusted for (a) expected credit loss of INR742m, which is non-recurring and (b) INR1.65b of provision write-backs. The QoQ drop in...

NMDC reported a healthy set of numbers for Q3FY19 on the back of better-than-expected realisations and higher-than-expected sales volume. Hence for the quarter topline, EBITDA, PAT came in notably higher than our estimates. The company reported a sales volume of 8.7 million tonne (MT), up 7.4% YoY, 29.9% QoQ, higher than our estimate of 8.1 MT. The topline came in at | 3649.4 crore, up 47.8% YoY, 49.7% QoQ, higher than our estimate of | 3177.9 crore EBITDA margin came in at 59.0% (49.0% in Q3FY18, 51.7% in...

31 January 2019 Adj. EBITDA increased 65% QoQ (+71% YoY) to INR22.8b in 3QFY19, 13% ahead of our estimate of INR20.2b, led by higher-than-expected realization. EBITDA is adjusted for (a) rail line doubling payment of INR528m and (b) expected credit loss of INR717m, which is non-recurring. Adj. PAT increased 63% QoQ (+76% Production increased 81% QoQ (+11% YoY) to 9.5mt, while sales grew 30% QoQ (+8% YoY) to 8.7mt, led by higher offtake from Chhattisgarh. Domestic realization increased INR550 QoQ to INR4,185/t, as against our estimate of INR3,668/t. EBITDA per ton increased 27% QoQ to INR2,618 (USD36), led by higher realization and operating leverage benefits. We raise our FY19 EPS estimate by 8% to account for the beat. Operations at the Donimalai mine remain suspended. However, we expect NMDC to eventually get its MLs renewed without sharing any revenue.

18 January 2019 Donimalai and Kumarswamy are NMDCs two mining leases (ML) in Karnataka with permitted annual production of 7mtpa each. Donimalai operations are temporarily shut pending a hearing in the High Court regarding unreasonable demand of 80% share in revenue as a condition for renewing the ML. The next court hearing is on 22 January 2019. Two MLs with total capacity of 17mtpa have already been renewed, which is half of current production. Renewal of other leases is in process. NMDC is currently shipping about 23mtpa iron ore from this complex. In the worst case if outcome in the Donimalai judgment is not favorable, NMDC will still have 17mtpa profitable capacity. Further, NMDC is confident that the Chhattisgarh government will not be as demanding as the Karnataka government. NMDC is creating a storage yard near Jagdalpur, which will debottleneck dispatches from Chhattisgarh by 4-5mt (to 28mt).

Donimalai mine. Unperturbed by the ongoing legal issue, we are rather more concerned on the i) structural risk to the domestic iron ore pricing and ii) sharp shrinkage in market share of merchant miners post auction of mines expiring by March-2020 in Odisha. Mine auctions benefit the manufacturer as it serves raw material security replacing the dependence on merchant miner at lower cost. It would act as the key enabler for capacity creation with no impact on State Govt's revenue from royalty. We downgrade NMDC to Reduce as we expect steep increase in Odisha's production (due to last year of...

Viability of NMDC's mining operations is threatened by Karnataka's pre-condition to share of 80% revenue for renewing mining leases of Donimalai, which has capacity of 4mtpa. The outcome of legal and diplomatic settlement may set a precedent for other mines. This was unexpected because public sector enterprises (PSEs) have been getting their leases renewed without sharing of any revenue - e.g. leases of Nalco's bauxite mines have been recently extended to 2029 and 2032without any share in revenue; many PSEs have been allotted coal blocks on a nomination basis

NMDC's Q2FY19 performance came in below our estimates. The company reported a sales volume of 6.7 million tonne (MT), down 19.2% YoY, 1.4% QoQ, lower than our estimate of 7 MT. The topline...