The 8 reports from 2 analysts offering long term price targets for Multi Commodity Exchange of India Ltd. have an average target of 1212.50. The consensus estimate represents an upside of 5.83% from the last price of 1145.70.
|Summary||Date||Stock||Broker||Price at Reco.||Target||Price at reco|
Change since reco(%)
|2019-10-16||Multi Commodity Exch..||HDFC Securities||1027.85||1175.00||1027.85 (11.47%)||Target met||Buy|
Regulatory tailwinds like Institutional participation, Indices and tie-up with Retail bank subsidiaries can boost trading volumes further and increase depth in the long run. Globally Institutional clients account for ~50% of the total derivatives volumes. We continue to remain constructive on the long-term growth opportunities and the concern related to increase in competition is behind us. There has been no impact of the whistle-blower letter and the physical delivery mechanism remains robust. We estimate revenue/PAT CAGR of 19/22% over FY19-22E. We see value in MCX based on (1) Embedded non-linearity, (2) ADTV growth, (3) Market leadership and (4) Net cash of Rs 14bn (~28% of Mcap). Risks include regulatory delays, increase in competition and drop in Bullion volumes and commodity volatility. We maintain BUY on MCX based on in-line revenue and margin beat in 2QFY20. Market share (94%) is increasing despite rise in competition. Embedded non-linearity and cost control is leading to margin expansion. We assign 30x to core Sep 21 PAT and add net cash (20% discount) to arrive at SoTP of Rs 1,175 (16% upside).
|2019-10-15||Multi Commodity Exch..||Motilal Oswal||1015.65||1250.00||1015.65 (12.80%)||9.10||Buy|
However, base metal volumes declined sharply due to (1) the SEBI's directive to allow trading of only one contract per commodity and (2) the switch from cash We expect volume/revenue/earnings CAGR (FY19-21) of 22%/24%/28%. Over the past few months, sentiment around MCX reversed from that of competition concerns to one of optimism largely driven by growth in bullion volumes. This is a reflection of the winner-takes-all nature of the business MCXs golden run in terms of volumes came at the time of significant run-up in gold and silver prices in FY12 and FY13. Over the last few months, sentiment around MCX has reversed from concerns around competition from the likes of BSE, to one of optimism, driven by multiple factors feeding into volumes growth. Its monopolistic market share has remained intact, and MCX has now ruled out the possibility of a price cut, which was earlier on the anvil.
|2019-09-05||Multi Commodity Exch..||Motilal Oswal||871.30||1000.00||871.30 (31.49%)||Target met||Buy|
5 September 2019 Those two international customers have been participating for some time now, and from November18 to June19, they bought the commodity and sold the same commodity. There is no remiss here and there is an opportunity to retest the quality. MCX retested and quality met the standards specified in the contract; the delivery too has been lifted. People tend to keep the stock on the delivery platform in order to be able to trade again. MCX entered into an agreement with a UK-based firm in July/August 2018 for gold and energy spot exchange platform development. Further enhancements will be taken care of by the internal tech team. Also, allegation of Chairman and Mr Paranjape travelling together to Europe is a figment of imagination. Three vaults where deliveries are given are in Ahmedabad. MCX had ~INR5b of insurance cover in two vaults and another INR10b in the third.
|2019-07-18||Multi Commodity Exch..||HDFC Securities||871.15||962.00||871.15 (31.52%)||Target met||Buy|
Regulatory tailwinds like Institutional participation, Indices and tie-up with Retail bank subsidiaries will boost trading volumes by ~10% and increase depth in the long run. Globally Institutional clients account for ~50% of the total derivatives volumes. We continue to remain constructive on the long-term growth opportunities, concerns on increase in competition and pricing pressure is gradually subsiding. The market is expanding with entry of new market participants and products. We estimate revenue/PAT CAGR of 18/15% over FY19-21E. We see value in MCX based on (1) Embedded non-linearity, (2) ADTV growth despite rising competition, (3) Market leadership and (4) Net cash of Rs 13bn (~30% of Mcap). Risks include regulatory delays and increase in competition. We maintain BUY on MCX based on in-line 1QFY20. The company has maintained market share despite increasing competition. Embedded non-linearity and cost control is leading to margin expansion. Regulatory tailwinds will boost volumes further. We assign 30x to core FY21E PAT and add net cash to arrive at SoTP of Rs 962 (13% upside).
|2019-04-26||Multi Commodity Exch..||HDFC Securities||838.70||950.00||838.70 (36.60%)||Target met||Buy|
MCX volumes can increase with regulatory tailwinds like institutional participation (MFs, PMS), launch of Indices, and partnership with retail bank subsidiaries. These can boost volumes by another 10%. The concern related to increase in competition and pricing pressure is subsiding. We don't see risk to existing volume and pricing. In fact, the market can expand with launch of innovative products and entry of new market participants. We estimate revenue/PAT CAGR of 18/14% over FY19-21E. We see value in MCX based on (1) Embedded non-linearity, (2) ADTV growth despite rising competition, (3) Market leadership and (4) Net cash of Rs 13bn (~30% of Mcap). Risks include regulatory delays and increased competition. We maintain BUY on MCX on in-line 4QFY19. The company has increased market share despite increasing competition. Cost control was impressive, led to margin expansion. We assign 30x to core FY21E PAT and add net cash to arrive at SoTP of Rs 950 (19% upside).
|2019-04-26||Multi Commodity Exch..||Motilal Oswal||838.70||950.00||838.70 (36.60%)||Target met||Buy|
26 April 2019 Income from operations increased 2.9% QoQ to INR791m (226bp beat to our estimate of INR774m). EBIT grew 24% QoQ to INR211m, with the margin at 26.6% (47bp beat). PAT increased 45% QoQ to INR610m (PAT margin of 55%), significantly ahead of our estimate of INR348m, mainly due to the recognition of a minimum alternate tax (MAT) credit of INR206m for the year. EPS for the quarter was INR12.0 v/s our estimate of INR6.8. Income from operations increased 16% to INR3,000m from INR2,580m in the previous year. EBIT increased 45% YoY to INR1,925.2m, with the margin at 26.5%. Net profit increased 34% YoY to INR1,446m from INR1,081m in FY18. EPS rose 34% YoY to INR28.4.
|2019-01-16||Multi Commodity Exch..||HDFC Securities||751.10||957.00||751.10 (52.54%)||Target met||Buy|
Maintain BUY with a TP of Rs 957, implying a P/E of 30x to Dec-20E core earnings and adding back net cash. MCX delivered good set of numbers in 3QFY19. Revenue was up 8.2% QoQ to Rs 0.77bn (in-line with our est. of Rs 0.77bn), led by 7.9% QoQ increase in volume (Rs 17.03tn). MCX maintained its market share at 91% and ADTV grew 7.9% QoQ, despite increased competition from NSE & BSE. EBITDA margin was down 496bps QoQ to 27.2% largely due to higher other expenses. Excluding one-off margin was up 89bps QoQ to 33.1% but still below our estimate of 34.9%. Hedging activity in bullions is witnessing increased traction with open interest built up while metals volume is impacted due to shift from cash to physical settlement.
|2019-01-15||Multi Commodity Exch..||Motilal Oswal||765.00||900.00||765.00 (49.76%)||Target met||Buy|
15 January 2019 Revenue grew 26% YoY to INR769m, in line with our estimate of INR766m. Futures volumes grew 34% YoY (+8% QoQ) to INR17t, dominated by crude (+78% YoY) and gold (+53% YoY). EBITDA margin of 27.2% (+500bp YoY, -500bp QoQ) was below our estimate of 34% due to higher other expenses (INR45m one-off). Excluding this one- time expense, the margin stood at 33.1% (90bp lower than our estimate). PAT growth of 124% YoY (to INR420m) exceeded our estimate of 68.5% YoY owing to higher other income (INR322m v/s our estimate of INR199m) and a lower tax rate (15.3% v/s our estimate of 24%), which emanated from some provisions and deferred tax. For 9MFY19, revenue/EBITDA/PAT were up 17.9%/47%/42% YoY. MCX highlighted that the uptick in volumes in recent past has not just been a function of volatility but also increasing participation. We expect volumes/revenue/earnings CAGR (FY18-21) of 20%/16%/22%.
|2018-10-24||Multi Commodity Exch..||HDFC Securities||816.45||980.00||816.45 (40.33%)||Target met||Buy|
Maintain BUY with a TP of Rs 980 implying a P/E of 30x Sep-20E EPS. MCX delivered muted set of numbers in 2QFY19, revenue was down 2.4% QoQ to Rs 711mn (vs our est. of Rs 734mn), led by 0.3% QoQ drop in volume (Rs 15.8 TN) and Rs 16.7mn impact from Liquidity Enhancement Scheme (LES). ADTV was up 1.2% QoQ and 12.2% YoY to Rs 246.55 bn led by Metals (+3.5%). Trading volume has picked-up in Sep-18, ADTV is at Rs 273.78bn (+22% YoY) led by Metals and Energy.
|2018-10-23||Multi Commodity Exch..||Motilal Oswal||742.05||875.00||742.05 (54.40%)||Target met||Buy|
23 October 2018 Revenue increased 5.7% YoY to INR711m (2% below our estimate of INR726m) in 2QFY19. Lower-than-estimated revenues in the case of MCX are explained by either realization (mix of high- and low-volume orders) or by contribution of non-transaction revenues. EBITDA margin of 32.2% missed our estimate of 38%, led by  lower revenues and  higher Software expenses (INR145m v/s estimate of INR115m). PAT increased 23.3% YoY to INR359m (7.6% beat) owing to a lower tax rate (13% v/s 25%), which emanated from some excess provisions written back and deferred tax. MCX is expected to start monetizing Options in FY20, and there will be no transaction charges in 2HFY19 either. We expect volumes/revenue/earnings CAGR (FY18-20) of 19%/13%/16%. In our view, this merits caution not only from the perspective of potential loss of market share, but also in terms of any unexpected cut in pricing in the near future.
|2018-07-23||Multi Commodity Exch..||HDFC Securities||768.50||1050.00||768.50 (49.08%)||Buy|
Maintain BUY with a TP of Rs 1,050 implying a P/E of 30x FY20E EPS. MCX delivered decent set of numbers in 1QFY19, revenue was up 3.2% QoQ to Rs 729mn (vs our est. of Rs 742mn), led by 5.5% QoQ rise in volume (Rs 15.8 TN) offset by 2.2% drop in realisations. ADTV was up 2.2% QoQ and 29.8% YoY to Rs 243.60 bn led by rise in Bullion (+5.7% QoQ) and Metals (+9.0%). Bullion volume has started to recover and current ADTV is only at 56% of the pre-demonitisation level, thus scope for catch-up is immense. Options volume jumped significantly (~12x) after introduction of LES in April-18 (ADTV of Rs 5.46bn vs Rs 0.46 in 3Q).
|2018-04-30||Multi Commodity Exch..||HDFC Securities||777.90||1040.00||777.90 (47.28%)||Buy|
Maintain BUY with a TP of Rs 1,040 implying a P/E of 30x FY20E EPS (earlier 35x). MCX delivered robust set of numbers in 4QFY18, revenue was up 12.4% QoQ to Rs 706mn (in-line with our est. of Rs 716mn), led by 17.8% rise in volume to Rs 15TN. Total ADTV was up 17.8% QoQ and 22.6% YoY to Rs 238.2 bn led by rise in commodity prices and volatility. Encouraging part is that volume traction is even stronger in April-18, ADTV is up 26% QoQ to Rs 299.3bn led by 13/27% rise in bullion and metals volume.
|2018-04-28||Multi Commodity Exch..||Motilal Oswal||799.00||1020.00||799.00 (43.39%)||Buy|
MCX's 4QFY18 revenues grew 15.8% QoQ to INR706m v/s estimate of INR694m. EBITDA margin expanded ~12pp QoQ to 34.1%, compared to our estimate of INR34.8%. PAT grew 81% QoQ to INR340, in line with our estimate of 343m.The smart growth in sequential financial performance was a function of 17%QoQ growth in volumes to INR15t.
|2018-03-27||Multi Commodity Exch..||Motilal Oswal||686.85||1050.00||686.85 (66.80%)||Buy|
Lackluster volumes in Options since its launch in October 2017 Universal licenses becoming effective in October 2018, allowing for entry of competition and, thus, putting MCX's market share under threat Recent media articles citing CBI investigations into wrong-doings by erstwhile Forward Markets Commission (FMC) officials in granting MCX a nationwide commodity derivatives exchange status, as well as relaxation of rules for promoter shareholding before the company's IPO in 2012
|2018-02-16||Multi Commodity Exch..||Motilal Oswal||749.00||1100.00||749.00 (52.96%)||Buy|
Overall volumes for MCX have been soft because of multiple issues (demonetization, GST, PMLA) reducing Bullion volume to nearly a half in a span of a year. Over 9MFY18, while volume in Bullion declined by 30% YoY, that in Base Metals increased by 17%, thereby stemming the overall volume decline to 8%. The contribution of Bullion to overall volume has now come down to 23% (from 30% last year), whereas that of Base Metals has moved to 43% (from 34%).
|2018-01-17||Multi Commodity Exch..||HDFC Securities||850.65||1165.00||850.65 (34.69%)||Buy|
Maintain BUY with a TP of Rs 1,165 implying a P/E of 35x Dec-19E EPS. MCX delivered bad set of numbers in 3QFY18, revenue was down 9.4% QoQ to Rs 610mn (our est. was Rs 615mn), led by 7.9% fall in ADTV. Options trading started in Oct-17 but the volume pick-up is very slow vs. expectation. Options ADTV stood at Rs 1.40bn (only 0.7% of futures ADTV, target is to reach 20-30% in the next six months). MCX is planning to launch four to five additional options contract in the next few months.
|2018-01-16||Multi Commodity Exch..||Motilal Oswal||896.40||1100.00||896.40 (27.81%)||Buy|
MCX's 3QFY18 revenue came in at INR610m, 2% below our estimate of INR621m, led by a slight decline in realization. Operating expenses stood at INR475m, exceeding our estimate of INR453m by 5% due to one-off expense (INR20m) toward events hosted by MCX in 3Q ??? excluding which operational results were in line. PAT of INR188m (below our estimate of INR283m) was dragged lower, as other income of INR156m missed our estimate by 39% due to MTM losses on fixed income instruments. The bullion-led volume decline at MCX commenced in Dec'16 ??? the month post demonetization. In the subsequent 12 months (Dec???16 to Nov'17), gold/silver volumes declined 47/31% YoY, leading to an overall volume decline of 17% YoY. However, with the quantum of decline reducing dramatically and the sharp uptick seen in base metal volumes (19% YoY), growth can be expected to return in the next quarter.
|2017-11-14||Multi Commodity Exch..||Motilal Oswal||949.00||1300.00||949.00 (20.73%)||Buy|
2) P. K. Bindlish CGM, Commodity Derivatives Market Regulation, SEBI 3) G. Mahalingam Whole-time member, SEBI 4) R. Amalorpavanathan Deputy MD, NABARD 5) Supriyo Bhattacharjee DGM, Financial Markets Regulation (FMRD), RBI 6) Dr. Rakesh Junjhunwala Rare Enterprises 7) Kevin Piccoli Deputy Director, US CFTC The discussion focused on a range of topics, such as the steps taken by the...
|2017-10-25||Multi Commodity Exch..||Axis Direct||1043.95||1280.00||1043.95 (9.75%)||Buy|
Revenue increased ~5% QoQ to Rs 915 mn due to higher traded value (up ~17% QoQ) led by bullion (up ~17% QoQ) and base metals (up ~32% QoQ). EBITDA margin (including float income) expanded to 23.6% (Q1: 13.7%) driven by operating leverage and flat cost even as yields led to lower float income.
|2017-10-14||Multi Commodity Exch..||HDFC Securities||1132.55||1342.00||1132.55 (1.16%)||Buy|
Maintain BUY with a TP of Rs 1,342, implying a P/E of 35x Sep-19E EPS. MCX delivered robust numbers in 2QFY18. Revenue was up 13.6% QoQ to Rs 673mn (our est. was Rs 688mn), led by 17% up-tick in ADTV, and offset by 1.2% fall in realisations. Bullion (29% of ADTV) recovered sharply (+17.5% QoQ), but is still down 40.7% in 1HFY18. Metals (39% of ADTV) recovered sharply (+31.9% QoQ) after GST implementation in July-17.